Skip to main content

Miriam

Leadership Development and Theory U

November 13, 2026

Leadership Development and Theory U

November 13, 2026
6:39 pm

Tending the Social Soil: Leadership, Presence, and the Conditions for Growth

By Miriam McCallum, MSc, MCC, EISA, EIA-SP

Having just returned from the Theory U Presencing Foundation Programme in Berlin – with Otto Scharmer, Julie Arts, Manish Srivastava, Arawana Hayashi, Olaf Baldini and Angela Baldini – I feel I am flourishing!

It was an amazing week. I met and connected with so many wonderful people all doing amazing work in the world, as consultants, as Leaders, as researchers, all of them – positive changemakers.

It is hard to summarise such a depth of learning, but the metaphor of the soil—what lies beneath the surface, the invisible earth that nourishes the visible plants above—tools, methods and techniques, touched me so deeply that I decided to write about it.

Think of a farmer preparing the soil. They may add nutrients, sow seeds, manage irrigation, use machinery, and draw on skill and experience to cultivate the ground. Yet the deeper work is not simply about technique; it is about creating the conditions in which life can take root. The soil is the invisible foundation of the harvest. In agriculture, we know that yield is not produced by seeds alone, or by methods alone, or even by the farmer’s intuition. It depends on the quality of the soil. Rich, nourished soil allows crops to grow and flourish. Depleted soil, no matter how carefully planted, limits what can emerge.

The very same principle applies in human systems, and gives us a different perspective on understanding and working with different levels of human systems.

In our relationships and organisations, there is a kind of social soil—the quality of trust, attention, listening, and shared intention that surrounds our interactions. This invisible ground shapes what can emerge between people. Just as in farming, we may focus on strategies, decisions, and actions, yet overlook the deeper conditions from which they arise.

Otto Scharmer’s Theory U invites us to shift our attention precisely to this deeper layer. It asks not only what we do, but from where we do it. Bill O’Brien’s insight captures this powerfully:

“The quality of an intervention depends on the quality of the internal condition of the intervener.”

In other words, the inner state of the leader—their openness, presence, and capacity to truly sense and respond—becomes the soil from which all action grows.

When the internal soil is hurried, reactive, or closed, even well-intentioned interventions can fall flat. But when it is grounded, attentive, and connected, something different becomes possible: conversations deepen, relationships strengthen, and new futures can take root.

So, the work of leadership is not only to act and ‘do’, but to cultivate and ‘be’ : To prepare the social soil. To tend one’s own inner ground.

There are many practices for tending the ‘social soil’  – so for now, here are  4 – and I invite you apply these right now, wherever you are.

Four Practices:

If the quality of the soil shapes what can grow, then perhaps our daily practice is to tend the conditions beneath the surface. These are small but powerful ways of cultivating the social soil in ourselves and with others:

1. Practise the quality of attention. Open Mind (1)

Before entering a conversation, meeting, or moment of decision, pause and notice where your attention is. Am I distracted, hurried, defended, or already forming a judgement? Am I closed to my own experience, or can I be open to something new? Even one conscious breath can shift the ground from reactivity to receptivity. It requires deep curiosity.

2. Practise listening beneath the words. Open Mind (2)

Listen not only for content, but for what is emerging underneath: the feeling, the need, the longing, or the possibility being expressed. This kind of listening asks us to suspend the impulse to fix, advise, or reply too quickly, and instead to receive more fully. This requires deep curiosity and focused attention – our minds and hearts are wide open.

3. Practise the quality of presence. Open Heart

Presence is the gift of being fully here. It means bringing our whole self into the room—body, mind, heart, and intention—so that others experience us as grounded and available. In this state, trust has more space to take root. It requires compassion and humility, so we can hold the space to meet the future that stays in need of us in the now.

4. Practise speaking from the field, not just from the self. Open Will

When we do speak, we can ask: is this contribution serving the whole? Is it true, necessary, and generative? Speaking in this way is less about performing or persuading, and more about giving voice to what wants to be said in service of the wider system. It requires courage and agency to hold spaces to crystalise the future we want to create.

Because in the end, whether in fields or in human systems, or at an individual ‘self’ level – what grows above the surface is always shaped by the quality of the soil we tend beneath it.

Search

Categories